July 2, 2007

Amarnath Shiva Lingam Melts Completely


An image of The Amarnath Cave and the Lingam as it is ordinarily.


Kaveetaa Kaul

Do we consider ourselves deuteragonists? Second most important in the Great Drama of Life? Or are we pretending to be so, out of ignorance? Or merely acting out our misconceptions? Or waiting for the veil of illusion to lift and expose that which lay behind was in fact a mirror of what lay hidden inside, Pure, Timeless, Intelligence, Deathless, Beingless, All Knowing…

In an unprecedented first, the Shiv Lingam at the holy cave of Amarnath in Kashmir has melted completely (completely in the title meant to emphasise ‘total dissolution’.. without an iota of doubt) creating a wave of disappointment in the lakh or so pilgrims gathered in Pahalgam en route Amarnath. July 1st, the first day of the pilgrimage and there was no lingam in the cave, as validated by the shrine authorities.

Does this mean therefore that Lord Shiva has deserted his abode?

The Shiv lingam is a natural ice stalagmite that waxes in the period between July to September in the holy months of Shravan and wanes thereafter. It is believed that Shiva Baba narrated the story of eternal life and immortality to Ma Parvati in that cave . The Shiv Lingam which formed naturally for thousands of years then grew to be known as one of the three abodes of Lord Shiva.

The visual of thousands of devotees expressing anguish over a melted Lingam and evincing sentiments such as ‘ What purpose will our visit serve now?” or ” If He is not going to be there then we are as if betrayed” gets one thinking real hard as to the purpose of the yatra ( pilgrimage) in the first place. Was it to see first hand a phenomenon of nature? Does the Lingam signify the truth of a living God as Shiva is believed to be? Does the melting down mean he has fled? If Shiva lives only in the Amarnath Lingam, does that mean therefore that the hundreds of Shaivite Temples spread across the length and breadth of India are but empty shrines? What is the underlying meaning behind a pilgrimage?

Well..definitely not a Nature trek!

While the cause attributed to the melting has been the regular advent of helicopters in the three helipads catering to the elitist niche of pilgrims who can for a mere Rs. 5’000 get to the shrine which otherwise is an arduous trek, global warming is rumored to be another.

Not a great believer in the ‘manifest’ that is ‘Aakar” but rather in the ‘unmanifest’ or ‘Nirakaar’ makes one proclaim that the presence of the Shiv Lingam has little to do with proof of Lord Shivas presence there. Subsequently the absence/ melting of the Ligam logically, is scant reason to express massive disappointment. The omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent Almighty behooves no proof. Tangible expressions do not necessarily validate Spiritual benevolence!

I have often thought pensively on the reason behind the holiest of shrines always being on the apex of a hill, mountain. The journey if arduous and long, intensifies the purpose, magnifies the longing and purifies ones intention. So much so that eventually, the Self has been elevated to a degree of cleansing that makes for a receptive medium.. If the insides are full of hatred, envy, anger, despair, ire, there is little that can be received. Only an empty receptacle can be replenished with blessings and energy. The Journey therefore is meant to be slow, determined and resolute, painstaking as if to test the mental and emotional strength of the pilgrim as also to scale his faith and belief!

I read this in utter astonishment. It as if condoned the above, if one cared enough to read the underlying meaning , as one ought to read scriptures.

In preparation to that He left His Nandi ( The Bull which He used to ride ) at Pahalgam (Bail gaon) . At Chandanwari He released Moon from his hairs (Jataon). At the banks of Lake Sheshnag He released the snakes . He decided to leave his Son Ganesha at Mahagunas Parvat (Mahaganesh Hill ) . At Panjtarni, Shivji left the Five Elements behind (Earth , Water, Air , Fire and Sky) which make living being . He is the Lord of these elements. It is believed that as a symbol of sacrificing the earthly world , Shivaji and Maa Parvati had Tandav Dance . After leaving behind all these, Bhole Shankar enters the Holy Amarnath Cave along with Parvati Maa .

Is the melting therefore a subtle manner of letting us know that Lord Shiva would rather have his pilgrims on foot or atleast try to be there with the aid of their own physical capacity rather than adopting a short cut route via helicopters?..Notice that He discarded Nandi the bull , (His mode of transport), The moon from his hairs and snakes, (bodily decorations, adornments, indicating austere clothing) his son Ganesha, (indicating earthly connections or emotional bonds, and finally all proof of bonds) That one would think is the mental preparation needed for a purposeful pilgrimage.

If only the legends of the Gods were imbibed devoid of blind faith and scrutinised for deeper hidden truths they embodied!

Finally, knowledge of the Self through whatever means suited is the purpose not just of spirituality but also of ones birth. Bhole nath or the eternal life energy within us has never been disconnected to have to find Him atop moutains. But reaching the apex of personal purification is the only roadblock which keeps Him from us.

Om namoh Shivay!


AddThis Social Bookmark Button



  1. Duh ???? couldnt understand what u were saying ….. :((

    Comment by Manoj — July 2, 2007 @ 4:54 pm | Reply

  2. LOl..At least you were honest. My bad perhaps..The point is that there have different levels through which I have dealt with this ostensibly material/physical phenomenon. Can you tell me what it is that you have not understood. Will a re-read help?

    Or maybe you tell me what does the melting of the lingam mean to you.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 2, 2007 @ 5:28 pm | Reply

  3. I am a keen follower of Advaitism or Non Dualism which is what you are referring to I think. For most the tangible becomes the rope by which they go higher. They forget to go beyond live without the help of the obvious, in this case the Lingam. I liked the interpretation of Shiv jis journey, and his discarding the non essentials. Novel, I must say…. have not heard of it before. Undertaking a pilgrimage with correct mindset is the most crucial aspect of the journey.

    Comment by dilip — July 2, 2007 @ 7:04 pm | Reply

  4. Hmm…Bholenath playing hide and seek with his children

    Comment by Nitin — July 2, 2007 @ 9:03 pm | Reply

  5. Hi Kaveeta,

    Personally ,this was the best blog i read in recent times .Great! Slow reading helped me understand the article …thought provoking & enriching indeed.Faith is power , logic has no place…I believe God dislikes over smartness like…helicopters,cable cars …..Are we looking for INSTANT NIRVANA ? no time for GOD it seems

    Comment by Laxmi — July 2, 2007 @ 9:32 pm | Reply

  6. @Dilip..on the dot

    @ Nitin..Hide n seek? As usual I guess 🙂

    @ Laxmi..Thanks.. Im glad it touched a chord..Instant Nirvana ..oh yeah>>so right. There are no shortcuts here. Diving deep within and recovering lost pearls is no easy task.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 3, 2007 @ 10:42 am | Reply

  7. Really thought provoking..Thanks for the good read.

    Comment by Krishnan — July 3, 2007 @ 12:50 pm | Reply

  8. Kaveetaa,check this out , this is an interesting site -this will answer some of your queries if not all :

    Comment by Laxmi — July 3, 2007 @ 9:44 pm | Reply

  9. Kaveetaa, check this out- this will answer some of our queries if not all , its really interesting :

    Comment by Laxmi — July 3, 2007 @ 9:46 pm | Reply

  10. The reason for this is clearly global warming. There are glaciers melting in Bolivia, on which the entire country’s water supply is dependant. Greenalnd many ice caps have melted. Ice bergs floated all the way from Antartica to New Zealand and caused a lot of problems. Even Himalayas have slowly started melting. Clearly there is a build up of greenhouse gases and a rise in sea temperature. Tow islands in Sunderbans has sunk , causing environmenatl refugees. The govts all over the world are paying lip service to this. This is a non profit issue, so only govts can do some thing

    Well if you are interested where Lord Shiva is interested in residing now , then see this
    web site , a slide show

    or visit

    Comment by gajanan — July 4, 2007 @ 7:31 am | Reply

    • Greetings. I would not dispute that global climate change is affecting the planet, however, I suggest that is not necessarily the case with the melted lingam at Amarnath cave. My wife and I trekked to Amarnath cave on the pilgrimage in late July or early August of 1974, along with an estimated 17,000 pilgrims. When we reached the cave there was no ice. The hike was indeed arduous and fulfilling in many ways. For me it was all about the journey and being in the moment. There were no helicopters around at that time. We observed a few individuals being borne up the mountain to the cave on palanquins. I enjoyed the website and thoughtful comments. I can still see Amarnath Cave in my mind’s eye some 37 years later. It would have been nice to see the ice on the full moon, but I am not disappointed.

      namaste, mitnadev, Miami, Florida..

      Comment by mitnadev — July 16, 2011 @ 8:05 am | Reply

      • Mitnadev.. I think you have probably gauged the essence of any pilgrimage. It is more the journey within oneself to that state of higher consciousness to feel Him who is always near but hidden. The Amarnath shrine, although legendary in its power to evoke divinity, the journey or pilgrimage also needs to be undertaken with a view to raise the inner self to the extent that he can be welcomed within, with or without the Lingam in full vision.


        Comment by Kaveetaa Kaul — July 22, 2011 @ 1:43 pm | Reply

  11. “living with the himalayan masters” by swami Rama is a must read book

    Comment by anonymous — July 4, 2007 @ 7:47 am | Reply

  12. @ Laxmi..Great link.. Thanks. Actually my questions were more rhetoric than anything else, meant to question the legitimacy of the pilgrims’ disappointments. Like stated earlier the Niraakaar fascinates me, being a keen student of Lord Buddhas Vippassana system of meditation.

    @ Hi Gajanan,

    Yes Gloal warming is creating havoc in unheard of ways already. The astounding part to do with this Lingam was that on the 20th of June when they beamed an image of it on the electronic media, it was shown as a massive one, bigger and well formed than the previous years. Within a matter of 10 days it just fizzles out into a mound of water is what is quite surprising. The reason attributed was that those pilgrims who wished to visit here ahead of the others, via helicopter had begun coming in hordes. The helipads three in number, coupled with global warming which perhaps accelerated the melting and final dissipation.

    Your link to do with the new temple is intriguing. Devotion paves paths in hitherto uncharted territories. But Bholenath is present in the cave as well.. perhaps grim over the grimness of Mans misdeeds.

    Perhaps you and Laxmi would like to read this:

    Its changed my life.
    Anonymous.. I have read Swami Ramas book.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 4, 2007 @ 10:29 am | Reply

  13. Kaveetaa, thanks for the link

    Comment by Laxmi — July 4, 2007 @ 1:59 pm | Reply

  14. Thanks to the indian army for playing with the sentiments of pilgrims and creating this mess

    Comment by anonymous — July 4, 2007 @ 8:11 pm | Reply

  15. Kaveetaji , you should read the biography of the founder of the institution in Hawaii. Please go thru the web site in detail. There are books which are great and you will know the meaning of Lord Shiva , Ganesha and Lord Kartik. Merging with Siva, Dancing with Siva , Loving Ganesha bks are all available online in the publication section. The founders biography is one all must read. Shivji ki Leela hai apaar.

    Global warming is an urgent matter for all in the world to take interest. It will affect everybody’s life. The rise in sea temp has already sunk two islands in the Sunderbans and about 1000 people have moved to some other place. This global warming being a non-profit area , there is dilly dallying by govts all over the world. Then there are people who oppose that there is no such thing a global warming. Yeh bhi bada toli hai. You have evidences right before your eyes of icebergs melting , ice mountains melting in Bolivia, which is the source of water supply there. Near Maldives the sea is rising and so many changes taking place. Then we have our own Amarnath Shiv Ling melting. If this procrastination over this issue continues, then we will not be able to sing the great song of Hemanda ” Shivji ke Mandir pe Palki lagaike”. We must prevent this and we must sing this song again and all should rejoice singing this song from Munimji

    Comment by gajanan — July 5, 2007 @ 4:48 am | Reply

  16. @ Anonymous,

    I agree. I saw a report yesterday where army officers without care or concern had jumped over the barricades around the Shiva Lingam, and in numbers…this was obviously shot prior to the melting and perhaps accelerated it. They then proceeded to pose for photographs standing close to the Lingam, with their arms almost around it, saved for posterity, showing off, as if on a trip to the zoo. So was this the purpose of their visit, a snap that would rid them of their sins? It was ridiculous. And to think that this was the army who were themselves indulging in such irresponsible behaviour!

    Gajanan Ji,

    Yes I have read a little and I will definitely go through the rest of the pages on the link in detail.

    Global warming is taking on monstrous proportions. You seem to be much informed on it. Would you like to do a post on it which I could post here on Sachiniti, attributed to you? It would be nice.

    “Shivji ke mandir me palki lagai ke”..Jai Bhole Nath

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 5, 2007 @ 12:27 pm | Reply

  17. I came across your blog and you are doing a great job ! all your posts are very interesting .I want you to go through this blog atleast once and if possible read all the posts , i read some of them and was really surprised with the way things happen in our conuntry , heres the link

    Comment by Ashok — July 5, 2007 @ 12:56 pm | Reply

  18. To write a full article and for an audience to grasp it, I will take some time, because I have to put across the message to all. Please give me some time. I will post one on ” Global warming and its impact with India as the focus”

    Comment by gajanan — July 6, 2007 @ 5:43 am | Reply

  19. @Ashok..I have read a few.. will do so again..Thanks.

    @Gajanan ji..Absolutely no problems. Whenever you are comfortable.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 6, 2007 @ 6:31 am | Reply

  20. on global warming – series of concerts around the world on 07-07-07.

    Comment by jidda — July 6, 2007 @ 1:31 pm | Reply

  21. Thanks Guys Jidda and Laxmi..

    Jidda that was a great link. On 6th night I will post a blog here with the link to Live Earth, and you as sender.. and the links that Laxmi has posted.. If you guys want to write some stuff on it send it to me I will post it along with these details.

    WE need to get upbeat about this crisis and motivate/ educate as many as we possibly can.



    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 6, 2007 @ 6:59 pm | Reply

  22. Amarnath Shiva Lingam Melts Completely

    Do we consider ourselves deuteragonists? Second most important in the Great Drama of Life? Or are we pretending to be so, out of ignorance? Or merely acting out our misconceptions? Or waiting for the veil of illusion to lift and expose that which lay b…

    Trackback by Anonymous — July 6, 2007 @ 7:11 pm | Reply

  23. Hi Kaveetaa ,

    please visit this link, i mentioned this on “VOTE FOR TAJ ” post … since there(taj post) the comments were churning out in large numbers i thought my comment might go unnoticed , sorry for posting the same comment twice.

    Comment by anonymous — July 7, 2007 @ 11:28 am | Reply

  24. Kaveeta please don’t misunderstand me , my only reason for posting this link was.., i came to know you graduated in world history and this looking at the other side of the “Taj story” (no offence intended)

    Comment by anonymous — July 7, 2007 @ 11:33 am | Reply

  25. Hi Anonymous..Thanks for the link

    Yes, I do know of this controversy. The point however is that either way Taj is our heritage structure unparallelled in its beauty form and perfection.So voting becomes all the more incumbent..dont you think? Whether it was Shah Jehan or not..if it promotes love, it ought to be Universally lauded. Lets get out of these man made prejudices,, they bind us. Lets taste freedom in its truest manner.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — July 7, 2007 @ 1:07 pm | Reply

  26. Amarnath Shiva Lingam Melts Completely Sachiniti

    The Shiv Lingam has melted on the first day of the Amarnath Yatra itself.Unprecedented.

    Trackback by Anonymous — July 11, 2007 @ 4:04 pm | Reply

  27. Amarnath Shiva Lingam Melts Completely

    Do we consider ourselves deuteragonists? Second most important in the Great Drama of Life? Or are we pretending to be so, out of ignorance? Or merely acting out our misconceptions? Or waiting for the veil of illusion to lift and expose that which lay b…

    Trackback by — July 13, 2007 @ 11:14 am | Reply

  28. […] of the Lord Shiva: The Shiv lingam is a natural ice stalagmite that waxes in the period between July to September in th… It is believed that Shiva Baba narrated the story of eternal life and immortality to Ma Parvati in […]

    Pingback by Andymatic » Amarnath Shiva Lingam, Sacred Ice Phallus, Melts Completely — July 16, 2007 @ 11:45 pm | Reply

  29. what you have said in the last stanza of the things given is exactly correct .. man who gives all his worldly emotions and bonds and pleasures truly … is the one who can be free in body and soul to get the utmost energy and divine blessings could be attained ……..

    Comment by s.rajesh — July 22, 2007 @ 3:10 am | Reply

  30. i

    Comment by muthu — September 19, 2007 @ 9:37 pm | Reply

  31. Hi,

    Learned a lot ………!!!!!!!!!!..Thanks for all who have immensely taken part on this and giving some valuabel links…….

    Comment by Venkat Raghav — September 20, 2007 @ 1:39 pm | Reply

  32. Very nicely written Kaveeta, logical and aware. This certainly provoked a lot of thoughts in my mind, albeit radical (as I am already) I like this line you wrote “I have often thought pensively on the reason behind the holiest of shrines always being on the apex of a hill, mountain.” – To this question, I might suggest looking into symbolism of concepts and penances (available aplenty in Puranas, mytho stories etc) – Since the area of God is so high, its alluding to the ascent an ordinary man/woman has to make in order to relish the joy of being with the divine (god or Atman), nowadays more prominently “sold” as pilgrimage….and to the point, my personal view is that this is clearly god’s way to say “Gimme sometime alone, please, for once!!” if he so chose to reside in those torrid zones! And we dont leave him alone even there….so he decided to take a break and go else where (the melting)….sincerely its just my lamentation about the gross misinterpretation of symbolism, faith and devotion in many Hindus, including myself, that we resort to find God only outside of ourselves, regarding the treacherous journeys, harsh climates as a “test” of our “will and faith” rather than acknowledging that we are probably better off in using such resolve to contemplate our self-conscious.

    Comment by Nanda Kalyan — December 3, 2007 @ 7:31 pm | Reply

  33. S.Rajesh and Venkat ..thanks a ton.

    Hi Nanda,

    your “my personal view is that this is clearly god’s way to say “Gimme sometime alone, please, for once!!”..certainly brought a smile to my face.

    You have struck upon various issues really ..exactly as I would have liked it while writing this piece. Te discussion about non duality or Dvaita Advaita is as old as the hills and perhaps will continue to the end of time. I guess some queries are meant never to be answered for the search to perpetuate timelessly.

    I find myself agreeing with you totally when you lament over the pursuance of finding God outside ourselves..since I am a keen Vippassana student, the meditation technique which finally led to Buddhas enlightenment and which makes us the sole creators of our spiritual destiny, denying the hand of god sitting high up in ‘harsh climates’.

    Paradoxically, like most humans however, I disagree when the Dvaita student in me raises its head and the faith and “Bhakti’ deeply ingrained theories strike out. I find myself precariously swinging between both these worlds, equally an adherent , passionately so of their guidelines. If faith be the cornerstone of spiritual progress, which experience shows me to be true, then I am well on my way. Simultaneously, if disregard for rituals and symbolic actions be the test of a true Advaita meditator, I may find myself in that category as well. If you recall , therefore I began by asking ‘do we consider ourselves deuteragonists’ in that sense.

    I also believe strongly in what I wrote above, to do with shrines being at places that call for an arduous trek ..”The journey if arduous and long, intensifies the purpose, magnifies the longing and purifies ones intention. So much so that eventually, the Self has been elevated to a degree of cleansing that makes for a receptive medium.. If the insides are full of hatred, envy, anger, despair, ire, there is little that can be received. Only an empty receptacle can be replenished with blessings and energy.”

    It is merely another way to get deep into our self conscious for those to who tangible assimilation of religious ideals is a must. All paths lead to the sun if interpreted metaphorically will elucidate my point. The sum total or bottom line remains an elevated and heightened sense of spiritual awareness.. As Vivekananda said’ You can be born in a church but dont die in one”..meaning progress is the only yardstick of inner growth. Human life has just this one goal..none other.

    Comment by kaveetaakaul — December 4, 2007 @ 2:49 pm | Reply

  34. stolen by the firangees!

    As i read from the internet, only two well known ‘nath’ sampradays are known in world right now: Adi-nath and Nandinatha Sampradaya.

    Adinath is the linage of the great Matsyendranath and Gorakhnath ji. the second last nath in this chain, initiated a ‘white’ who near the time of his death, declared – no more initiation of Indians!!! and only whites!
    [Shri Gurudev Mahendranath (April 29, 1911–August 30, 1991) was a British occultist, real name: Lawrence Miles in London, England founder of International Nath Order (originally Western Nath Order) after getting initiation(mistake) by Shri Sadguru Lokanath of Uttarkashi, India into adi-nath sampraday, Shri Pagala Baba of Ranchi initiated(mistake) him into the tantrik Uttara Kaula. Later(result) this guy decided: ” As Guru of these ancient sects, Shri Mahendranath resolved not to pass on the Indian Sannyasi initiation into these sects. He made no new Indian sadhus. ”

    so a British, in the end, stole the great tantra and linage too…

    same with Nandinath linage, the reins has been handed over to a white who has settled in Hawaii and 1)is not accessible to ordinary hindus. 2)whites get the privilege and preference for doing prayer, knowledge etc. over Indians.

    Those who know Shiv-Puran, plz. read the story of durgam-danav (killed by Devi Durga).

    the great lord SadaShiv has also said that knowledge should be given to the ‘right’-person only.

    the real knowledge and essence of hindu religion is being silently stolen by west, and here we are discussing what?

    my heart cries.

    har har mahadev!
    jai bharat maa!

    Comment by badeguruji — December 6, 2007 @ 9:35 am | Reply

  35. ‘Real knowledge ‘ can never be stolen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    If you pledge by Mahadeva then understand first that whatever happens is His WILL.

    Comment by DP — December 7, 2007 @ 4:09 pm | Reply

  36. I have tried to find pictures of both before and after, does anyone know where a few good ones are located on the web?

    Comment by Alex — February 25, 2008 @ 1:21 am | Reply

  37. it is a miricale happens in amarnath lord is present in the world it is true who ever says lord is not or no they would reailize this one a most to belive in god shiva i love lord shiva please send me some pictures of lord shiva in amarnath

    Comment by veni — March 8, 2008 @ 7:03 am | Reply

  38. Somethings to think abt…

    Many of us ignore facts and suppress our own inquisitiveness, suppress our own understanding deep down in our hearts to avoid strife, tension between peers etc…Confusing? What is the meaning of shiv ling and its shape? Some know but yet shy away from re-thinking it, some who don’t know can easily find it on the web!

    What is my point? People are born and are raised in a religion. Some stay, some leave. Those who shy away from their inner instincts are the ones who have more probability of staying, but still struggling to be satisfied with what their faith is all about. Those who search for the truth, prompted to respond to their inner instincts, leave their faith or stay if it really makes sense. Confusing?

    People of India…listen to your heart deep down. Do you really think that these symbols signify the presence of God? You live for 70 years and you think you either become non-existent or come as another being? Do you really believe deep down that this is your fate? I have struggled with my faith in which I was born but now have found the trophy of my quest, God! Why shouldn’t I speak to everyone about it? Many of you have zeal, a zeal for the faith in which you were born. But your own heart cannot accept the things which you would like to believe, because it doesn’t exist. Your zeal without the knowledge of the truth will take you to the pits of hell where there is only darkness, anguish and suffering and you will realize that it is neither your re-incarnation nor your non-existence. I am in no way inclined to speak against you or your beliefs. I know the zeal I had for my faith in which I was born. I had no knowledge nor satisfaction of my heart until I found what I have come to believe. Confusing?

    Would you trade-in 70 years of zeal for wrong things, so that you follow your family tradition, so that you don’t offend your parents, so that you be blinded by your own zeal? or Rather would you look, open your eyes and listen to your heart and search for the thing that is real?
    Would you trade-in 70 years of decent living on earth for eternity in abyss? or Rather would you smack you brains and get to work to find the truth, so that you can spend eternity with the real God?
    Please India, time the deal with the pretensions and bring the facts to the table and deal with it. Let the people who are bound by spiritual darkness be released by this truth. Jesus Christ is this Truth. He is waiting for you to seek Him. Call upon Him and He will answer. Jesus saves from eternal fire (hell)!Don’t let it be too late.

    Comment by tj — March 22, 2008 @ 11:18 am | Reply

  39. @tj : Do you really think Jesus Christ, Go and search the truth for yourself, he was just a normal man who happen to learn Buddhism in India from age 14 to 29 and went back to Israel and preached it to his followers on this own way which you guys now say Christianity(The Most Modified Religion of All Time). And your jesus christ, just like other normal human being like you and me, died at the age of 80 in India in Jammu and Kashmir. So go and clear your doubts and come back to the Only One Truth and the only way of Life i.e. Sanatan Dharma AKA Hinduism.



    Comment by Sanatan Dharma — April 12, 2008 @ 5:06 am | Reply

  40. Many adults in the United States are concerned about climate change, according to a poll by Rasmussen Reports. 47 per cent of respondents think global warming is a very serious problem, while 26 per cent deem it as somewhat serious.

    Comment by Alec — April 16, 2008 @ 2:59 pm | Reply

  41. in response to badeguruji, I’d like to point out that the initiations he refers to were freely given, not “stolen”. Second, there seems to be some misunderstanding that because a couple of guruparamaparas passed to Westerners, that Indians are somehow deprived of the many other Nath guruparamparas which remain to this day in India. How could that be!

    Comment by Adityanath — April 18, 2008 @ 12:13 am | Reply

  42. Dear Sir,
    If i want to visit amarnath yatra what is flight fare of this which traveles is best for this yatra.Please let me know the deatiles of this tour programe.

    Comment by AMARNATH — April 28, 2008 @ 6:04 pm | Reply

  43. jai ho baba BHOLE nath ki..Har Har MAHADEV

    Comment by Nitin Tayal — May 30, 2008 @ 1:39 pm | Reply

  44. You have deep knowledge about Amarnath have a look at this page and tell what better we can add to this.

    Comment by Amarnath Travel Yatra — June 12, 2008 @ 2:57 pm | Reply

  45. probably the most informative and thought provoking article that i have had the pleasure to read in a very long time, thank you

    Comment by SUSHMA RAVAL — July 21, 2008 @ 8:39 pm | Reply

  46. Thanks a ton to you Sushma 🙂

    Comment by Kaveetaa Kaul — July 22, 2008 @ 1:56 pm | Reply

  47. Reply to Badeguruji

    The Nandninatha Sampradaya followed in Hawaii by cannot be considered as a stolen one. The founder Siva Subramuniyaswami , an American was a disciple of Sage Yogaswami who lived in Sri Lanka. Sage Yogaswami lived some time with Ramana Maharishi , who sat in one place and attracted many followers Indian as well as westerners like Paul Brunton, Arthur Osbourne and Somerset Maugham who wrote the book Razor’s Edge based on Ramana MRishi. Ramana still contnues to spellbound many with his great question ” Who am I? is based on translations from Tamil and they have done a great job by clearing the misconceptions of Hinduism , Aryans , Dravidians , which was hoisted on India by British for colonising. I would not call them stealing as they have acknowledged everything to India and Santan Dharma. Many of my friends have visited this place and were recd as equal as westerners and there is no ill feeling towards if you are a Vaishana or Shaiva, for they have understood Hindu ethos well.

    Come to your point of westerners and Sanatan Dharma. The west even with its religions does not have a equivalent word to Gnana in their dictionary. Swami Vivekananda emphasised this very well in his collected works. Yes Gnana is not intuition , but beyond intution, something which cannot be comprehended.

    The best example in modern times to expalin Gnana is the genius Maths wizard Srinivass Ramanujan. Srinivasa Ramanujan;s family were worshippers of Shakti ( Nammakkal Goddess). I need not elaborate , but Ramanujan went to Cambridge and did work with Prof Hardy and Prof Littlewood. It is said , three to four times , he wrote maths continously for hrs , not knowing the difference between day and night. This made the Profs not understand what this genius is doing for hrs and that too very accurately. When asked Ramanujan replied ” Goddess Namakkal is the inspiration” Ramanujan was in trans as if in meditation. This is what Gnana is all about , which these two Prof allowed him to do and he wrote some great maths which is used in space and computer science in a big way. The Prof’s said to Ramanujan ” This is great stuff , please continue and he went on and on with his epoch making maths like a Gnana Yogi.

    The West and the religions will find it difficult to decipher the meaning of Gnana. Some even called it Mumnbo Jumbo or mysticism. Even now many are not able to comprehend Gnana means to go beyond frontiers.

    One feels that the monks in Hawaii have done a commendable job in clearing out the misconceptions of Sanatan Dharma and explain to the world that Gnana is uniquely Sanatan and it is all inclusive of Sanatan Dharma’s gift to the troubled world.

    Comment by gajanan — July 29, 2008 @ 7:46 am | Reply

  48. Really a thought provoking article which will compel many to do a soul searching before embarking upon such a pilgrimage.

    Comment by Mrinal Patir — August 6, 2008 @ 12:50 pm | Reply

  49. Thanks Mrinal

    Comment by Kaveetaa Kaul — August 7, 2008 @ 8:12 am | Reply

  50. Reply to Sushma

    Thank you kaanan 😀

    Comment by Ab — August 20, 2008 @ 3:55 am | Reply

  51. I did not understand a single bit. Would have been much clearer had it been written in a simple language that milions of laymen like me can understand rather than for a handful of intellectuals. May be some day you would think like a genius and pen it down like a layman.

    Comment by Kannan — August 22, 2008 @ 11:01 pm | Reply

  52. Good One

    Comment by kasi — December 18, 2008 @ 11:18 am | Reply

  53. Hi Kaveeta,

    Awesome thought provoking article 🙂


    Yogi (

    Comment by Yogi — January 15, 2011 @ 12:30 am | Reply

  54. hey baba rammohan apki sharan me hai….

    Comment by ram mohan shukla — April 8, 2011 @ 9:51 am | Reply

  55. hey baba bhole nath ashok apki sharan me hai……(hey prabhu sbi associte me meri naukari laga do……)

    Comment by ASHOK VERMA — May 6, 2011 @ 10:23 am | Reply

  56. jai baba sabki suno aur meri bhi suno.

    Comment by ANUJ VERMA — June 30, 2011 @ 1:57 pm | Reply

  57. I really like your interpretation of YATRA, and the real meaning behind Amarnath Srine visit

    Comment by karthik — July 21, 2011 @ 6:24 am | Reply


    ashok turki Dhar

    Comment by ASHOK TURKI — September 1, 2011 @ 9:05 pm | Reply


    Comment by ASHOK TURKI — September 1, 2011 @ 9:06 pm | Reply

  60. hey do u all believe in god?///

    Comment by natasha — November 24, 2011 @ 8:04 pm | Reply

  61. 62.remark=kavitha as xlent…………………………………… very good ……….really see this .

    Comment by vikas (ap) — December 7, 2011 @ 1:41 am | Reply

  62. bhahuth acha hai jindhagi me ak bar dekna chatha u apna shiva ka bhakth my thanks namashkar………///////om namashivaya

    Comment by shathrudhan yadav (nepal janakpur) — December 7, 2011 @ 1:48 am | Reply

  63. Jai baba barfani

    Comment by Diwakar shankar — October 24, 2012 @ 8:11 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: